
The premise sounds like a sketch that overstays its welcome: Maya Erskine and Anna Konkel, both in their early thirties, play versions of their thirteen-year-old selves in the year 2000, surrounded by an entire cast of actual thirteen-year-olds who treat them as peers. For the length of a cold open, it is funny in the way stunt casting is funny. By the third episode, it isn’t a stunt anymore. It’s just how the show sees adolescence — from slightly outside it, which turns out to be the only honest angle available.
Why the Device Works
Putting adults in the bodies of children, without prosthetics or de-aging, does something a straight teen cast can’t: it removes the safety of watching pretty people be sad prettily. Maya and Anna are awkward on purpose and also just awkward, full stop, and the show lets the gap between how they see themselves and how they’re actually seen do the comedic and emotional work simultaneously. A crush scene plays as farce and as something close to unbearable at the same time, because we’re watching a grown woman’s face do what a thirteen-year-old’s face does when it doesn’t yet know how to hide anything. That’s the trick: the age gap isn’t a joke about age, it’s a magnifying glass on how much thirteen actually costs you, filmed at a scale adults can bear to look at directly.
What It Gets Right
The show is unembarrassed about the specific humiliations of being thirteen in a way most coming-of-age television flinches from — masturbation, body hatred, the particular cruelty kids deploy on each other without understanding its weight yet. It doesn’t sand any of it down for likability, and Maya and Anna’s actual friendship (they wrote it together, played best friends who are also somewhat different, one white and one half-Japanese, and the show doesn’t treat that as incidental) gives the whole thing a floor to fall back on. It is also, improbably, one of the funnier things made in this genre in years. The comedy and the ache are the same muscle here, not alternating scenes.
The Reservation
The device that makes the show remarkable is also the thing that will lose some viewers permanently, and not always the ones you’d expect. It’s not that it reads as creepy — the show is careful, and the real child actors are never put in compromising positions with the adults playing their friends — but the uncanniness never fully resolves, and a handful of viewers simply cannot stop seeing two adult women rather than two thirteen-year-olds, which flattens scenes that are meant to land as painfully sincere. If you’re one of those viewers, no amount of good writing will fix it for you, and that’s worth knowing before you commit rather than after two episodes of waiting for it to click.
Newsletter
Growing up, one season at a time
Get The Hallway in your inbox. No spam, and one click to leave.
Weekly, on Wednesdays · Unsubscribe any time. We never sell or rent your address; read the privacy policy.